A phone lying face down on the arm of a sofa beside a folded blanket, with morning light across a white wall behind it

It depends which body you ask, and this post quotes both. The American Academy of Pediatrics says video chatting with a baby should not be considered screen time, and has treated it differently from other screen media for infants since 2016. The World Health Organization’s guidance, which says screen time is not recommended under 1 year, does not mention video chat at all.

If you are wondering about the FaceTime with grandparents rather than the cartoons, that is the honest state of the guidance: one body carves it out explicitly, the other does not address it. What follows is what each says, in its own words, what a video call is and is not, and where an app like ours sits, which is not inside the exception.

What does the American Academy of Pediatrics say?

The Academy’s Center of Excellence on Social Media and Youth Mental Health answers this exact question on its parent-facing pages. Its page on video chatting with infants and toddlers says this should not be considered screen time, calling it relationship time instead, and notes that the Academy has permitted video chatting for infants since 2016.

The reasoning is stated rather than assumed. Video chatting, the page says, is usually brief, involves a lot of language exposure, and can help parents of infants feel supported. It adds that toddlers of around 18 to 24 months begin to understand that the person on the screen is a real person, and that research shows toddlers can pick up vocabulary from responsive video interactions with adults. Responsive is the word doing the work: someone on the other end who answers.

The Academy’s page on screen time for infants gives the wider frame. Children younger than 2, it says, learn best from exploring the world around them and playing with other children and adults. It asks parents to limit screen time for infants and to focus on co-viewing any content together, and it gives video chat as its example of a digital device used well: using FaceTime or similar apps to video chat with family members.

The HealthyChildren.org page on screens and infants is blunter about everything else. Infants cannot otherwise learn much from screens at this age, it says, so media such as cartoons or nursery rhyme videos are not recommended. The exception it names is the same one: FaceTime, Skype or other video chats can be beneficial to help build relationships between your child and other loved ones. The same page adds that if you do put on any media for your infant, it suggests brief use of educational programs.

What does the World Health Organization say?

Something different in shape, and it needs stating in full because this site sells a screen app.

The World Health Organization’s guidance for children under five, published in 2019, says that for infants under 1 year, screen time is not recommended. For 1-year-olds, sedentary screen time, which it describes as watching TV or videos or playing computer games, is not recommended. For children aged 2 to 4, sedentary screen time should be no more than 1 hour a day, and less is better. When a child is sitting still, the guidance says, reading and storytelling with a caregiver is encouraged.

The guidance does not mention video chat, video calls, FaceTime or any equivalent. It defines the thing it is limiting as sedentary screen time and gives television, videos and computer games as its examples. It does not say a video call is inside that definition and it does not say it is outside it. This post is not going to decide that on the World Health Organization’s behalf. Our screen time page states the full guidance and nothing beyond it.

So does FaceTime count?

Under the Academy’s guidance, no: a video call with a responsive person is the thing it says not to count as screen time. Under the World Health Organization’s guidance, the question is not answered, because the document is about sedentary time in front of television, video and games, and it does not carve anything out.

That is less tidy than the internet would like, and it is the truth of the two documents. What a parent can take from the Academy’s pages is that a baby learns very little from a screen, and that what makes a call different is the person on the other side of it, answering. Whether any of it belongs in your day is your call and your pediatrician’s.

What is a video call, and what is it not?

The Academy’s reasoning gives the test. A call is brief, it is full of a familiar voice saying the baby’s name, and it responds. Grandma waits for the baby to look, then waves. That is closer to a visit than to television.

It is not a show. The same phone, propped up and playing a nursery rhyme video on repeat, has none of those properties, and the Academy’s pages say so directly. It is not a babysitter either: the Academy’s tips for video calls are all about the parent staying in the frame, narrating, pointing at the screen, playing peekaboo and singing, and explaining when the picture freezes. The call works because an adult is holding it together at both ends.

Nor is it long. Brief is in the Academy’s definition of why video chat is different. A call that runs for an hour because the baby is quiet has drifted out of the reasoning that excused it.

Is this the same as the Screen Time setting on an iPhone?

No, and the two questions share a search phrase, which is why this one comes up. Apple’s Screen Time feature is a tally of app use on the device, and whether a call appears in that tally is a question about the software, not about the baby. Nothing in either body’s guidance has any connection to what a phone counts on its own report. If you arrived here for the settings question, this is not that page.

Where does a baby app fit?

Outside the exception, and we would rather say so than let you assume otherwise. Tiny Paws is not a video call. There is no responsive person on the other end of it; there is one heavy black and white animal on one bright color, which blinks, moves and makes its sound when a small hand lands on it. The person in the loop is you, sitting beside the baby and naming the animal out loud, and that is the only reason it is worth the few minutes.

So it sits inside the guidance that applies to screens, not in the carve-out for calls. Screen time is not recommended for infants under 1 year, sedentary screen time is not recommended for 1-year-olds, and for children aged 2 to 4 it should be no more than 1 hour a day, with less being better. The app is built with that in mind: no levels, no streaks, no rewards, no autoplay and no ads, so nothing in it is designed to keep a child looking. You pay once, and it ends when you put it down.

Long before any of that, a newborn is working with a face at close range and not much else. How far a newborn can see explains why the grandparent on the call is a blur to a baby of a few weeks, and when babies see color covers what arrives over the months after. For the first stretch, the best call is the one where the baby hears a familiar voice and you hold the phone, and the rest of the time, the best screen is your face.

Sources